Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Hope's avatar

I enjoy your thinking.

The frustration you express regarding the "asterisk"—the idea that domestication or specific lineages are simply "exceptions to the rules"—suggests you are brushing up against a genuine problem of language. This is not a matter of philosophical fluff, but rather a structural mismatch between your data and your terminology.

The core of the issue is that you are observing a process, but the system of taxonomy requires a category.

Throughout the piece, you describe evolution as a series of verbs: diverging, mixing, replacing, introgressing. You describe a world of gradients and "taxonomic tangles." Yet, the conclusion of the scientific process is almost always the assignment of a noun: Bos cf. baikalensis or Denisovan.

The "species problem" you mention is often treated as a lack of sufficient data—the idea that if we just had more genomes, the boundaries would become clear.

But your comparison between bovines and hominins suggests the opposite: that the more data we have, the more we realize that the "boundary" itself is a linguistic fiction.

When you ask if Denisovans are "really" a species, you are essentially asking if a noun can accurately describe a fluid, shifting population that exists in a state of constant gene flow. The answer is no—not because the science is incomplete, but because a noun is a static tool, and evolution is a dynamic process.

This is why the "asterisk" feels so unsatisfying. To say that domestication is an "exception to the rules of speciation" is to admit that the "rules" (the nouns) are failing to describe the reality (the process). It frames the biological reality as a "glitch" in the system, rather than framing the system as a clumsy approximation of the reality.

You do not need to turn this into a treatise on the philosophy of language, but there is a powerful opportunity here to pivot the conclusion. Instead of wondering if Yak X is "really" a different species, you could argue that the "species" label is a heuristic—a useful shorthand—that we are now outgrowing.

By pointing out that the "taxonomic tangle" of the bovine is a mirror of the hominin, you are not just comparing two animal groups; you are demonstrating that the tension between "the name" and "the genome" is a universal feature of mammalian evolution. The "problem" is not with the yaks or the Denisovans; it is with the insistence that nature must fit into a dictionary.

I am a low vision communicator who uses assistive technology.

To the memory of the Blessed Margaret Pole

Rothari's avatar

Wondering how many potential domestication or semi domestication efforts started and stopped, or even succeeded before failing eventually and getting wiped from the record.

8 more comments...

Ready for more?